| Date | Location | Result | |
| Nov 12, 2016 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein University 49, Marietta College 21 | Box score |
| Nov 05, 2016 | University Hts., OH | John Carroll 49, Otterbein University 6 | Box score |
| Oct 29, 2016 | Westerville, Ohio | Mount Union 66, Otterbein University 7 | Box score |
| Oct 22, 2016 | Berea, Ohio | Otterbein University 33, Baldwin Wallace 30 | Box score |
| Oct 15, 2016 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein University 45, Heidelberg 38 | Box score |
| Oct 08, 2016 | New Concord, Ohio | Otterbein University 30, Muskingum 17 | Box score |
| Oct 01, 2016 | Westerville, Ohio | Capital University 42, Otterbein University 41 | Box score |
| Sep 24, 2016 | Westerville, Ohio | Ohio Northern Univ. 16, Otterbein University 10 | Box score |
| Sep 17, 2016 | Wilmington, OH | Otterbein University 52, Wilmington 7 | Box score |
| Sep 03, 2016 | Buffalo, NY | Buffalo State 29, Otterbein University 26 | Box score |