| Date | Location | Result | |
| 02/20/16 | Rike Center -- Westerville, Ohio | Heidelberg 79, Otterbein University 69 | Box score |
| 2/17/16 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Marietta College 80, Otterbein University 56 | Box score |
| 2/13/16 | Capital Center | Capital 76, Otterbein University 59 | Box score |
| 2/10/16 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Wilmington College 87, Otterbein University 54 | Box score |
| 02/06/16 | Ursprung Gymnasium; Berea, Ohio | Baldwin Wallace 88, Otterbein 64 | Box score |
| 02/03/16 | University Hts., OH - DeCarlo Center | John Carroll 95, Otterbein University 48 | Box score |
| 1/30/16 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Otterbein University 76, Muskingum University 75 | Box score |
| 01/27/16 | ONU Sports Center, Ada, Ohio | Ohio Northern men 100, Otterbein 92 | Box score |
| 1/23/16 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Mount Union 94, Otterbein University 61 | Box score |
| 01/20/16 | Wilmington, OH-Raizk Arena in Hermann Ct | Wilmington Fightin' Quakers 74, Otterbein Cardinals 64 | Box score |
| 01/16/16 | Marietta, Ohio - Ban Johnson Arena | Marietta College 109, Otterbein 58 | Box score |
| 1/13/16 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | John Carroll 94, Otterbein University 80 | Box score |
| 01/09/16 | Seiberling Gymnasium | Heidelberg 100, Otterbein 89 | Box score |
| 12/30/15 | Cleveland, Ohio - Horsburgh Gymnasium | Case Western Reserve 91, Otterbein 83 | Box score |
| 12/29/15 | Cleveland, Ohio - Horsburgh Gymasium | Otterbein 60, Wheaton (Ill.) 56 | Box score |
| 12/19/15 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Capital University 77, Otterbein University 60 | Box score |
| 12/16/15 | Muskingum Recreation Center | Otterbein 93, Muskingum 89 | Box score |
| 12/12/15 | Alliance, Ohio - The MAAC | Mount Union 92, Otterbein 82 | Box score |
| 12/5/15 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Baldwin Wallace 80, Otterbein University 69 | Box score |
| 12/2/15 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Ohio Northern 87, Otterbein University 84 | Box score |
| 11/25/15 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Hiram College 76, Otterbein University 71 | Box score |
| 11/21/15 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Marian Univ. (Ind.) 87, Otterbein University 74 | Box score |
| 11/20/15 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Otterbein University 69, Denison University 67 | Box score |
| 11/17/15 | Springfield, Ohio (Pam Evans Smith) | Wittenberg 71, Otterbein 41 | Box score |
| 11/14/15 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Ohio Wesleyan University 80, Otterbein University 75 | Box score |