| Date | Location | Result | |
| 02/18/17 | Rike Center -- Westerville, Ohio | University of Mount Union 73, Otterbein University 57 | Box score |
| 02/15/17 | ONU Sports Center, Ada, Ohio | Ohio Northern men 98, Otterbein 55 | Box score |
| 2/11/17 | New Concord, Ohio (Anne C. Steele Ctr.) | Muskingum 80, Otterbein University 67 | Box score |
| 02/08/17 | Rike Center -- Westerville, Ohio | Wilmington College 87, Otterbein University 83 | Box score |
| 02/04/17 | Rike Center -- Westerville, Ohio | Baldwin Wallace University 78, Otterbein University 64 | Box score |
| 02/01/17 | University Hts., OH - DeCarlo Center | John Carroll 97, Otterbein University 58 | Box score |
| 01/28/17 | Tiffin, Ohio | Seiberling Gymnasium | Heidelberg 71, Otterbein 61 | Box score |
| 01/25/17 | Marietta, Ohio - Ban Johnson Arena | Marietta College 94, Otterbein 75 | Box score |
| 1/21/17 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Capital University 70, Otterbein University 47 | Box score |
| 01/18/17 | Wilmington,OH-Raizk Arena at Hermann Ct. | Wilmington Fightin' Quakers 87, Otterbein Cardinals 58 | Box score |
| 01/14/17 | Ursprung Gymnasium; Berea, Ohio | Baldwin Wallace 76, Otterbein 61 | Box score |
| 01/11/17 | Rike Center -- Westerville, Ohio | John Carroll University 82, Otterbein University 58 | Box score |
| 01/07/17 | Alliance, Ohio- The MAAC | Otterbein 86, Mount Union 84 | Box score |
| 01/04/17 | Rike Center -- Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein University 60, Ohio Northern University 50 | Box score |
| 12/30/16 | Rike Center -- Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein University 66, Waynesburg University 53 | Box score |
| 12/29/16 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Otterbein University 71, Washington & Jefferson College 55 | Box score |
| 12/17/16 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Otterbein University 60, Muskingum University 57 | Box score |
| 12/10/16 | Capital Center, Columbus, Ohio | Capital 75, Otterbein 67 | Box score |
| 12/6/16 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Marietta 79, Otterbein 54 | Box score |
| 12/3/16 | Westerville, Ohio | Heidelberg 70, Otterbein 53 | Box score |
| 11/29/16 | CAPITAL CENTER | Otterbein 72, Ohio Wesleyan 66 | Box score |
| 11/27/16 | Rike Center -- Westerville, Ohio | Denison 66, Otterbein University 59 | Box score |
| 11/22/16 | Branch Rickey Arena; Delaware, Ohio, USA | Wittenberg 56, Otterbein 49 | Box score |
| 11-19-16 | Beaver Falls, PA | Otterbein 69, JOHNJAY 60 | Box score |
| 11-18-16 | Beaver Falls, PA | Pitt Bradford 63, Otterbein 59 | Box score |