| Date | Location | Result | |
| 02/16/19 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Baldwin Wallace 82, Otterbein 62 | Box score |
| 02/13/19 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | John Carroll 84, Otterbein 75 | Box score |
| 2/9/19 | Anne C. Steele Center | Muskingum 70, Otterbein 69 | Box score |
| 02/06/19 | ONU Sports Center, Ada, Ohio | Ohio Northern men 75, Otterbein 70 | Box score |
| 02/02/19 | Westervill,e Ohio -- Rike Center | Mount Union 66, Otterbein 61 | Box score |
| 1/30/19 | Hermann Court | Wilmington (Ohio) 82, Otterbein 60 | Box score |
| 01/26/19 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Capital 93, Otterbein 61 | Box score |
| 01/23/19 | Marietta, Ohio | Marietta 96, Otterbein 67 | Box score |
| 01/19/19 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Otterbein 92, Heidelberg 88 | Box score |
| 01/16/19 | Westerville, OHio -- Rike Center | Otterbein 92, Ohio Northern 78 | Box score |
| 01/12/19 | Alliance, Ohio | Mount Union 95, Otterbein 68 | Box score |
| 01/09/19 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Wilmington (OH) 104, Otterbein 75 | Box score |
| 01/05/19 | Berea, Ohio | Baldwin Wallace 91, Otterbein 74 | Box score |
| 12/30/18 | Tampa Prep | Maryville (Tenn.) 71, Otterbein 62 | Box score |
| 12/29/18 | Tampa Prep | Otterbein 100, DePauw 79 | Box score |
| 12/18/18 | University Hts., OH - DeCarlo Center | Otterbein 81, John Carroll 79 | Box score |
| 12/15/18 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Muskingum 77, Otterbein 55 | Box score |
| 12/08/18 | Tiffin, Ohio | Heidelberg 87, Otterbein 76 | Box score |
| 12/01/18 | Bexley, Ohio | Capital 89, Otterbein 56 | Box score |
| 11/28/18 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Otterbein University 76, Denison University 65 | Box score |
| 11/25/18 | Columbus, Ohio - The Capital Center | Wittenberg 89, Otterbein 67 | Box score |
| 11/20/18 | Branch Rickey Arena; Delaware, Ohio, USA | Ohio Wesleyan 82, Otterbein 76 | Box score |
| 11/17/18 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Otterbein University 81, Oberlin College 67 | Box score |
| 11/13/18 | Westerville, Ohio -- Rike Center | Marietta College 98, Otterbein University 66 | Box score |
| 11/9/18 | Spurlock Center | Franklin 84, Otterbein 77 | Box score |