| Date | Location | Result | |
| Apr 25, 2009 | Westerville, OH | Otterbein College 5, Capital University 3 | Box score |
| Apr 25, 2009 | Westerville, OH | Capital University 4, Otterbein College 3 | Box score |
| Apr 23, 2009 | Westerville, OH | Otterbein College 5, Heidelberg 4 | Box score |
| Apr 23, 2009 | Westerville, OH | Otterbein College 6, Heidelberg 3 | Box score |
| Apr 18, 2009 | Alliance, OH | Mount Union 4, Otterbein 0 | Box score |
| Apr 18, 2009 | Alliance, OH | Mount Union 7, Otterbein 4 | Box score |
| Apr 17, 2009 | Westerville, OH | Otterbein College 6, Baldwin-Wallace 2 | Box score |
| Apr 17, 2009 | Westerville, OH | Baldwin-Wallace 7, Otterbein College 2 | Box score |
| Apr 16, 2009 | Delaware, Ohio, USA | Ohio Wesleyan 5, Otterbein 3 | Box score |
| Apr 16, 2009 | Delaware, Ohio, USA | Ohio Wesleyan 2, Otterbein 0 | Box score |
| Apr 11, 2009 | Muskingum College | Muskingum College 8, Otterbein College 0 | Box score |
| Apr 11, 2009 | Muskingum College | Muskingum College 3, Otterbein College 0 | Box score |
| Apr 08, 2009 | Wilmington, Ohio | Otterbein College 6, Wilmington College 4 | Box score |
| Apr 08, 2009 | Wilmington, Ohio | Otterbein College 10, Wilmington College 0 | Box score |
| Apr 04, 2009 | Westerville, OH | Marietta College 10, Otterbein College 7 | Box score |
| Apr 04, 2009 | Westerville, OH | Marietta College 5, Otterbein College 0 | Box score |
| Apr 02, 2009 | Westerville, OH | Case Western Reserve 7, Otterbein College 5 | Box score |
| Apr 02, 2009 | Westerville, OH | Otterbein College 4, Case Western Reserve 3 | Box score |
| Apr 01, 2009 | Ada, Ohio | Ohio Northern 15, Otterbein 1 | Box score |
| Apr 01, 2009 | Ada, Ohio | Ohio Northern 1, Otterbein 0 | Box score |
| Mar 30, 2009 | Westerville,OH | Otterbein College 2, Wittenberg 1 | Box score |
| Mar 30, 2009 | Westerville, OH | Wittenberg 5, Otterbein College 1 | Box score |
| Mar 27, 2009 | University Hts | Otterbein 7, John Carroll 4 | Box score |
| Mar 27, 2009 | University Hts., OH | John Carroll 5, Otterbein 4 | Box score |
| Mar 24, 2009 | Arizona | Otterbein College 10, Calvin College 0 | Box score |
| Mar 24, 2009 | Arizona | Otterbein College 3, St. Catherine 0 | Box score |
| Mar 23, 2009 | Arizona | Otterbein College 9, Buena Vista 0 | Box score |
| Mar 23, 2009 | Arizona | Otterbein College 4, St. Olaf 3 | Box score |
| Mar 21, 2009 | Arizona | Gustavus Adolphus 9, Otterbein College 0 | Box score |
| Mar 21, 2009 | Arizona | Otterbein College 2, North Central 1 | Box score |
| Mar 20, 2009 | Arizona | Gustavus Adolphus 11, Otterbein College 3 | Box score |
| Mar 20, 2009 | Arizona | Otterbein College 4, St. Joseph's 0 | Box score |
| Mar 19, 2009 | Arizona | Otterbein College 11, Trinity Christian 1 | Box score |
| Mar 19, 2009 | Arizona | Central 4, Otterbein College 0 | Box score |
| Mar 12, 2009 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein College 3, Denison University 2 | Box score |
| Mar 12, 2009 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein College 4, Denison University 3 | Box score |