| Date | Location | Result | |
| May 04, 2012 | Ada, Ohio | Ohio Northern 11, Otterbein 1 | Box score |
| May 04, 2012 | Ada, Ohio | John Carroll 5, Otterbein 4 | Box score |
| Apr 29, 2012 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein University 6, Capital University 3 | Box score |
| Apr 29, 2012 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein University 6, Capital University 1 | Box score |
| 4/26/12 | Tiffin, Ohio | Otterbein University 4, Heidelberg 3 | Box score |
| 4/26/12 | Tiffin, Ohio | Heidelberg 4, Otterbein 2 | Box score |
| Apr 22, 2012 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein University 7, Ohio Wesleyan 1 | Box score |
| Apr 22, 2012 | Westerville, Ohio | Ohio Wesleyan 4, Otterbein University 3 | Box score |
| Apr 21, 2012 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein University 7, Muskingum University 3 | Box score |
| Apr 21, 2012 | Westerville, Ohio | Muskingum University 4, Otterbein University 2 | Box score |
| Apr 19, 2012 | Wooster, Ohio | Otterbein University 3, College of Wooster 1 | Box score |
| Apr 19, 2012 | Wooster, Ohio | College of Wooster 3, Otterbein University 1 | Box score |
| Apr 17, 2012 | Marietta, Ohio | Otterbein 9, Marietta College 4 | Box score |
| Apr 17, 2012 | Marietta, Ohio | Marietta College 6, Otterbein 0 | Box score |
| Apr 15, 2012 | University Hts., OH | John Carroll 2, Otterbein 0 | Box score |
| Apr 15, 2012 | University Hts., OH | John Carroll 2, Otterbein 1 | Box score |
| Apr 11, 2012 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein University 8, Wilmington College 0 | Box score |
| Apr 11, 2012 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein University 6, Wilmington College 5 | Box score |
| Apr 06, 2012 | Ada, Ohio | Ohio Northern 10, Otterbein 1 | Box score |
| Apr 06, 2012 | Ada, Ohio | Ohio Northern 5, Otterbein 1 | Box score |
| Apr 04, 2012 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein University 4, Kenyon College 3 | Box score |
| Apr 04, 2012 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein University 11, Kenyon College 6 | Box score |
| Mar 31, 2012 | Alliance, Ohio | Otterbein 7, Mount Union 4 | Box score |
| Mar 31, 2012 | Alliance, Ohio | Otterbein 7, Mount Union 1 | Box score |
| Mar 29, 2012 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein University 7, Mount St. Joseph 4 | Box score |
| Mar 29, 2012 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein University 10, Mount St. Joseph 3 | Box score |
| Mar 27, 2012 | Cleveland, Ohio | Case Western Reserve 8, Otterbein 3 | Box score |
| Mar 27, 2012 | Cleveland, Ohio | Otterbein 10, Case Western Reserve 6 | Box score |
| Mar 25, 2012 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein University 4, Baldwin-Wallace 3 | Box score |
| Mar 25, 2012 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein University 10, Baldwin-Wallace 2 | Box score |
| Mar 22, 2012 | Springfield, Ohio | Wittenberg 3, Otterbein 0 | Box score |
| Mar 22, 2012 | Springfield, Ohio | Otterbein 3, Wittenberg 2 | Box score |
| Mar 16, 2012 | Kissimmee, Fla. | Otterbein University 3, Anderson 2 | Box score |
| Mar 16, 2012 | Kissimmee, Fla. | Utica College 6, Otterbein University 1 | Box score |
| Mar 15, 2012 | Kissimmee, Fla. | McDaniel College 4, Otterbein University 0 | Box score |
| Mar 15, 2012 | Kissimmee, Fla. | Otterbein University 7, Framingham State 1 | Box score |
| Mar 15, 2012 | Kissimmee, Fla. | Otterbein University 1, Austin College 0 | Box score |
| 03/13/12 | Kissimmee, Fla. | Wheaton (MA) 5, Otterbein 4 | Box score |
| Mar 13, 2012 | Kissimmee, Fla. | Otterbein University 10, Daniel Webster 0 | Box score |
| Mar 12, 2012 | Kissimmee, Fla. | Otterbein University 6, Rutgers-Camden 3 | Box score |
| Mar 12, 2012 | Kissimmee, Fla. | Otterbein University 10, Defiance College 1 | Box score |
| Mar 11, 2012 | Kissimmee, Fla. | Otterbein University 4, Roger Williams 0 | Box score |