| Date | Location | Result | |
| May 18, 2019 | Wooster, Ohio | College of Wooster 13, Otterbein University 3 | Box score |
| May 17, 2019 | Wooster, Ohio | Case West. Reserve U 4, Otterbein University 2 | Box score |
| 5/11/2019 | Fishers Field | Otterbein 7, Heidelberg 3 | Box score |
| 5/10/2019 | Fishers Field | Otterbein 7, Ohio Northern 1 | Box score |
| 5/9/2019 | Fishers Field | Otterbein 2, Baldwin Wallace 1 | Box score |
| 5/6/2019 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein 9, Penn St.-Behrend 0 | Box score |
| 5/6/2019 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein 1, Penn St.-Behrend 0 | Box score |
| May 05, 2019 | Marietta, Ohio | Otterbein 8, Marietta College 1 | Box score |
| May 05, 2019 | Marietta, Ohio | Otterbein 10, Marietta College 8 | Box score |
| May 02, 2019 | Oberlin, OH | Otterbein Univ. 13, Oberlin College 8 | Box score |
| May 01, 2019 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Otterbein 6, Thomas More 6 | Box score |
| 4/30/2019 | Westerville, Ohio | John Carroll 9, Otterbein 6 | Box score |
| 4/30/2019 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein 9, John Carroll 1 | Box score |
| 4/27/2019 | Fishers Field | Baldwin Wallace 13, Otterbein 1 | Box score |
| 4/27/2019 | Fishers Field | Baldwin Wallace 7, Otterbein 2 | Box score |
| 4/24/2019 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein 4, Mt. St. Joseph 3 | Box score |
| Apr 16, 2019 | Ada, Ohio | Ohio Northern 8, Otterbein 3 | Box score |
| Apr 16, 2019 | Ada, Ohio | Ohio Northern 7, Otterbein 4 | Box score |
| 4/13/2019 | Westerville, Ohio | Capital 7, Otterbein 4 | Box score |
| 4/13/2019 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein 7, Capital 6 | Box score |
| Apr 11, 2019 | Wooster, Ohio | Otterbein University 10, College of Wooster 3 | Box score |
| 4/9/2019 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein 10, Wilmington (Ohio) 8 | Box score |
| 4/9/2019 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein 11, Wilmington (Ohio) 2 | Box score |
| 4/6/2019 | Tiffin, Ohio | Heidelberg 6, Otterbein 1 | Box score |
| 4/6/2019 | Tiffin, Ohio | Otterbein 11, Heidelberg 8 | Box score |
| 4/3/2019 | Florence, Ky | Otterbein 9, Mt. St. Joseph 0 | Box score |
| 4/2/2019 | New Concord, Ohio | Otterbein 10, Muskingum 8 | Box score |
| 4/2/2019 | New Concord, Ohio | Muskingum 9, Otterbein 5 | Box score |
| Mar 28, 2019 | Delaware, Ohio, USA | Ohio Wesleyan 20, Otterbein 4 | Box score |
| 3/23/2019 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein 13, Mount Union 7 | Box score |
| 3/23/2019 | Westerville, Ohio | Otterbein 6, Mount Union 2 | Box score |
| 3/20/2019 | Westerville, Ohio | Bluffton 7, Otterbein 6 | Box score |
| 3/19/2019 | Westerville, Ohio | Ohio Wesleyan 5, Otterbein 3 | Box score |
| 3/16/2019 | Lexington, Ky. | Wis.-Oshkosh 7, Otterbein 4 | Box score |
| 3/15/2019 | Lexington, Ky. | Otterbein 6, Transylvania 3 | Box score |
| 3/10/2019 | Fort Myers, Fla. | Otterbein 6, Vassar 3 | Box score |
| 3/9/2019 | Fort Myers, Fla. | Otterbein 9, Augustana (Ill.) 8 | Box score |
| 3/8/2019 | Fort Myers, Fla. | Otterbein 3, Merchant Marine 2 | Box score |
| 3/7/2019 | Fort Myers, Fla. | Otterbein 7, Alvernia 2 | Box score |
| 3/6/2019 | Fort Myers, Fla. | Saint John's (Minn.) 6, Otterbein 0 | Box score |
| 3/4/2019 | Port Charlotte, Fla. | Otterbein 8, Bluffton 3 | Box score |
| 3/3/2019 | Port Charlotte, Fla. | Otterbein 8, Misericordia 3 | Box score |
| 3/2/2019 | Port Charlotte, Fla. | Mitchell 6, Otterbein 3 | Box score |
| 3/2/2019 | Port Charlotte, Fla. | Misericordia 14, Otterbein 3 | Box score |
| 2/26/2019 | Westfield, Ind. | Anderson (Ind.) 8, Otterbein 7 | Box score |